claims

Carrier Contacts

For your convenience, we’ve built this claims contact information list for the insurance carriers we work with. If a claim should arise after our normal business hours, or should you need immediate assistance, you can use the number to reach your carrier directly. Clicking any of the links below will open the specified carrier’s claim reporting web page.

Carrier

Phone

Fax

Claim Reporting Site

A. Central Mutual
800.234.6926   
N/A nycm.com
Allegany Co-Op
877.346.0300 585.968.6016   alleganygroup.com
Amtrust North America
866.203.3037 866.203.3037  amtrustgroup.com
Chubb 800.252.3037 800.300.2538   chubb.com
Dryden Mutual
800.782.0154  607.257.0624 drydenmutual.com
Erie & Niagara
716.632.5433 716.632.0410
enia.com
Foremost Insurance Group
800.527.3907 N/A
foremost.com
Genesee Patrons Co-Op
800.343.6469 585.343.5036 gpins.net
GMAC
800.325.1088 336.726.2300  gmac123.com
Hanover
800.682.0250 N/A hanover.com
Hartford Commercial 800.327.3636 800.347.8197 thehartford.com
Hartford Personal
800.243.5860 877.536.4765  thehartford.com
Markel Insurance
800.362.7535       
 855.662.7535     
markelinsurance.com
Merchants Insurance Group
800.462.1077 N/A merchantsgroup.com
National Grange (Main Street America)
877.425.2467
 877.282.3844 msagroup.com
New York Central Mutual
888.234.6926 607.965.2136  nycm.com
Philadelphia
800.765.9749 800.685.9238  phly.com
Preferred Mutual
800.333.7642
607.847.6616  preferredmutual.com
Progressive
800.776.4737
877.280.5587  progressive.com
Safeco
800.332.3226
N/A safeco.com
Travelers (Commercial)
800.238.6225
N/A travelers.com (IE Only)
Travelers (Personal)
800.252.4633 N/A
travelers.com
Utica National
800.274.1914 315.734.2680  uticanational.com